Unraveling a Local Mystery: What Happened to the Old Fain Theatre in Livingston, TX?

In the heart of Livingston, Texas, there once stood a cinematic gem: the Fain Theatre. For decades, it served as a hub for popcorn-fueled date nights, weekend matinees, and movie premieres that lit up the streets of small-town East Texas.

But then… it disappeared.

No major press release. No farewell screening. Just boarded windows, silent halls, and a growing wave of rumors, nostalgia, and confusion.

So, what really happened to the old Fain Theatre? Let’s take a look at the facts, the folklore, and what could be next for this piece of Livingston history.

🎞️ The Glory Days of the Fain Theatre

Locals remember the Fain Theatre as more than just a place to watch movies—it was a social centerpiece.

• Opened in the mid-20th century (exact date varies depending on who you ask)
• Classic marquee signage lit up downtown Livingston
• Regular showings of Westerns, summer blockbusters, and family films
• Popcorn that somehow always tasted better than it had any right to

It wasn’t a megaplex, but it didn’t need to be. For residents of Livingston, Onalaska, and surrounding communities, the Fain Theatre was an anchor of weekend tradition.

🕵️ So Where Did It Go?

The simple truth? It closed. Like many small-town theaters across America, the Fain struggled to keep up with:

• The rise of streaming services
• Competition from larger cinemas in Lufkin or Houston
• The cost of digital projection equipment
• Declining foot traffic in the downtown area

By the late 2000s, the Fain Theatre had quietly shuttered. Some say it was temporary. Others say it was “just until renovations.” But the lights never came back on.

🧃 Rumors and Theories That Won’t Die

Since then, the empty space has become something of a local mystery box. You’ll hear stories like:

• “A haunted projection room kept workers away”
• “A renovation was approved, but the budget vanished”
• “Someone from out of state bought it and then just… disappeared”
• “It’s full of old equipment and reel-to-reel ghosts”

And of course:

• “It’s going to be a wine bar now.” (Isn’t it always?)

🧱 What’s There Now?

Depending on when you drive by, you’ll either see:

• A mostly untouched shell of a building
• Talk of conversion into retail or event space
• Nothing at all but quiet dust and fading paint

There’s no official city plan publicly available for what will become of the Fain, but it’s clear the space still holds emotional real estate for a lot of longtime locals.

🎬 Should It Be Brought Back?

Some in the community think so. Reviving it as:

• A retro cinema with limited showings
• A community theater or performance space
• A local arts venue for music, markets, and open mics

It may take funding, coordination, and some old-school optimism—but the nostalgia is there. If the community wants it bad enough, who knows?

🗣️ Locals Remember…

“That was where I saw my first movie without my parents.”
“We used to all meet up there on Friday nights.”
“It wasn’t just a theater—it was our theater.”

If walls could talk, the old Fain Theatre would still be telling stories—and most of them would smell faintly like buttered popcorn.

📌 Want to See More Local Spotlights?

Visit www.onalaskatexas.com for stories, events, and features that keep the heart of small-town East Texas alive.